San Francisco Department of Public Health Data Breach (November 2018)

San Francisco Department of Public Health reported a data breach to the California Attorney General on Oct 3, 2019. It was also reported to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office for Civil Rights. The filing says the breach happened between Nov 14, 2018 and Aug 7, 2019, 323 days before it was reported. It affected 622 people.

Oct 3, 2019Reported
Nov 14, 2018Breach date
622People affected
2 regulatorsFiled with

What Happened

“On August 8, 2019, Alluma, a third party company that processes Healthy San Francisco enrollments, informed us that due to a computer error, some letters to Healthy San Francisco participants were sent to the wrong addresses between November 2018 and August 2019. These letters were reminders to renew Healthy San Francisco participation and informed participants when their coverage expired.”

From the sample notice letter San Francisco Department of Public Health filed with the California Attorney General (read the full letter)

On November 14, 2018, the covered entity (CE), San Francisco Department of Public Health, filed a breach notification report after discovering a computer error that caused its business associate (BA), Alluma, to mislabel letters and send them to the wrong people. This incident affected the protected health information (PHI) of 622 individuals and included paper records and films that contained demographic information. The CE provided breach notification to HHS, affected individuals, and the media. Following the breach, the CE investigated the incident and implemented new technical safeguards. OCR obtained copies of the CE’s policies and procedures, documentation of administrative safeguards, and its BA agreement. As a result of OCR’s investigation, the CE added a step to its quality control process for renewal notices.

Case summary from the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office for Civil Rights

What Was Exposed

According to the official filings, the breach involved:

Not everyone affected had every item exposed. Your letter says which of your details were involved.

What to Do Now

If Medical Information Was Exposed

  1. Read the "explanation of benefits" statements from your health plan, and question any care you did not receive.
  2. Ask your providers for a copy of your records if you suspect someone used your identity for treatment.
  3. Be careful with calls about "your recent treatment" asking you to confirm details or pay.

What to Do Now

  1. Read the notice letter carefully: it should say what was exposed, when, and what the organization is offering (often free credit monitoring).
  2. If anything sensitive was involved, a free credit freeze with Equifax, Experian and TransUnion is the strongest single step.
  3. Watch for phishing that mentions the breach. Contact the organization only through phone numbers or websites you find yourself.
  4. Keep the letter: you may need it for a claim, a settlement or a dispute later.

For Everyone Affected

  1. Watch for phishing that mentions the breach. Contact the organization only through phone numbers or websites you find yourself.
  2. Keep the letter: you may need it for a claim, a settlement or a dispute later.

Official Filings

Filed WithDatePeople AffectedSource
California Attorney GeneralOct 3, 2019–Notice and sample letter
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office for Civil RightsOct 3, 2019622HHS breach portal

Other Breaches Reported by San Francisco Department of Public Health

ReportedOrganizationPeople Affected
May 11, 2018San Francisco Department of Public Health900

All San Francisco Department of Public Health breaches ›

Similar Breaches Reported Around the Same Time

ReportedOrganizationPeople AffectedIndustry
Oct 3, 2019University of Alabama at Birmingham19,557Healthcare
Oct 4, 2019Gary Smith and assoc inc DBA gary smith agency2,000Healthcare
Oct 4, 2019The Methodist Hospitals, Inc.68,039Healthcare
Oct 4, 2019Euphemia R. Brumskine, MD, LLC850Healthcare
Oct 4, 2019Defense Health Headquarters3,500Healthcare
Oct 2, 2019Humana Inc756Healthcare

Questions

Is the San Francisco Department of Public Health data breach letter legitimate?
San Francisco Department of Public Health filed a breach notice with the California Attorney General and U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) Office for Civil Rights on Oct 3, 2019. If your letter matches those details, it is likely genuine. Still, don't use phone numbers or links from an email you weren't expecting; look up the organization yourself.
Can I sue San Francisco Department of Public Health or claim compensation?
It depends on what was exposed, whether you lost money or time because of it, and the laws where you live. Large breaches sometimes lead to class actions and settlements, which are announced by a court-appointed administrator. A lawyer can tell you where you stand.
How many people were affected?
San Francisco Department of Public Health told HHS that 622 people were affected.